Beware: this documentary is gritty and shocking.
I thought I'd pretty much decided for myself that she was not guilty back when I read this book, but this documentary makes me think again. But then I have to wonder why she would go along with this documentary if she really was guilty.....why put the question out there again? And to be fair, she was ultimately acquitted.
I still stand by her not being very likeable and not making very good choices......this doc puts that on full display. But again, as I said in the previous linked post, being stupid isn't a crime. I felt like this doc tried to humanize her and was really working to make the audience empathize. I mean, there she is in her lint-picked sweater, cooking in her small kitchen, surrounded by cats. That's cute and all, but skeptics still have questions.
This case reminds me a lot of the West Memphis Three case and its subsequent books and films....it looks like a local inept police department rushes to judgment in order to put the quiet town at ease. In the end, the saddest thing of all is that there's still no closure on who killed any of the victims in either case. (Even the guy who went to jail here still maintains his innocence.)
This piece also makes a case for the torrential current of media on the case and how inappropriate it can be at times. Maybe we all just have too much of a thirst for blood and salaciousness. Maybe that's why fictional crime shows are so popular. We're begging to be shocked and titillated.
And all at the cost of young lives and freedom. When crimes like these are committed what can we really do once it's done? Other than pursue justice, of course. But can we ever go back to the more kinder and gentler time when some details remained in the records and for private audiences only? And privacy and respect were valued above tawdry headlines? That's a journalistic pipe dream of mine for sure.
And even though I doubt she would ever read this post, I really don't wish a single bad thing to Amanda Knox. If she's truly innocent, I truly feel sorry for her. Her life has pretty much been ruined by simply having a roommate who was murdered. But if she is guilty or is implicit in any way, the personal hell she is living in is deserved. Not all crimes are punished by imprisonment behind walls and bars. Some are of our own making.
